To Kill a Muggle: Connections between Harry Potter and To Kill a Mockingbird?

Before I was Mr Multilingual, I was a teenager who read Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird for CXC English Literature, and J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series for fun. I have considered myself a fiction writer since my early teens, and lover of reading from before that. My time in 4th and 5th form English Lit, as well as university Literatures in English made me a lot more conscious of themes, tropes, etc in the stories I read and write.

Even so, you can imagine my surprise when I found what seemed to be a set of possible connections between the sixth installment in the Harry Potter series Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince and Mockingbird. Half-Blood Prince was indeed one of my favourite, if not my absolute favourite of the Harry Potter books; so I spent a lot of time thinking about it after I read it. I’ve been sitting on this for years (since 2005, to be exact!), wondering if I should ever share it online. Then finally, I thought, Why not?

So, here goes!

What possible connections could there be between these two books? They are separated by genre and decades, after all.

Spoiler Warning

Despite superficial appearances, Harry Potter and Mockingbird both deal with issues of prejudice and discrimination. The “pure-blood” hang-ups that Harry meets as he enters the wizarding world could easily be seen as a veiled reference to race issues of our world that young Jean Louise has to make sense of in Mockingbird. So, it might actually not be surprising that there be some connections between these two books.

So what connections did I see? To put it simply, they’re in the stories of the Ewell family of Mockingbird and the Gaunt family of Half-Blood Prince:

The Ewell family is on the outskirts of white society, poor and living in filthy conditions. The Gaunt family, a family of “pure-blood” wizards whose story is told in Half-Blood Prince, are poor and dirty, too and, by virtue of their “purity”, only above the “half-bloods” and “mud-bloods”, those with Muggle (non-wizard) ancestry who are, arguably, the “niggers” of the wizarding world, but at the bottom of the pure-blood ladder.

The connections don’t end there. Now, they start taking an interesting turn, including even letters of the alphabet, which really took me by surprise: Mayella Ewell is treated horribly by her father; Merope Gaunt is treated horribly by her father. Mayella becomes interested in Tom Robinson, a black man; Merope is interested in Tom Riddle, a Muggle. Both Toms are ultimately killed because of the advances.

Of course, how Mayella and Merope go about seeking these forbidden affections are markedly different. But wow, what a connection, nonetheless. Needless to say, it made my reading of the Harry Potter series even more enjoyable!

So… is it a coincidence? A tribute Rowling makes to Mockingbird, and to Lee? Am I just grasping at straws? Whatever the case, it was fun to make these connections. What do you guys think?

The power of language; the power of art! I love reading and writing!

RIP, Harper Lee! You have left a powerful legacy behind!

This entry was posted in Non-language issues and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s